In the last week of August 2025, the rain that arrived across Bordeaux was the kind of rain that rewrites a vintage. Three months of drought had hardened the soils. The summer had been one of the hottest in recent decades. By the time the canopies were closing in on hydric stress, the conventional wisdom had already written 2025 as a heavy year of high alcohols and weight. Then 60 to 90 millimeters fell across the region in the space of a few days. Pierre-Olivier Clouet at Cheval Blanc has since described what came of it with the line that will follow the vintage: “2010 without the alcohol.”
The wines, against expectation, are saline and chalky. The fruit reads blue and red rather than dark and roasted. Tannins are firm but cool. Concentration arrived in the absence of weight, helped by yields that came in sharply below 2016 levels. Decanter’s correspondents, having tasted more than 800 wines across three weeks of barrel samples, returned a verdict of balance and poise. It is the rare warm year that wears its warmth lightly.
A Chorus That Mostly Agrees
The critic class is unusually aligned at the top of the vintage, and unusually candid about what sits beneath it. James Suckling’s team, after a sweep of barrel samples across dozens of estates, places the best 2025s at the level of 2019 and 2016. Antonio Galloni titles his Vinous report “Le Freak” and calls the finest wines “nothing short of thrilling,” while warning that the appellation as a whole is inconsistent. Neal Martin’s “Hot Body, Cold Blood” captures the central paradox in five words: warm-vintage structure inside a cool-vintage profile.
Like this? The TERROIR Letter arrives every Thursday.
Where the consensus thins is below the first growths and the limestone Right Bank stars. The drought stressed Pomerol’s gravel-and-clay terraces more than it stressed the water-retaining limestone plateau of Saint-Émilion. Médoc cabernet picked after September 20 gained plushness from the rain without losing the freshness the late season delivered; cabernet picked earlier, or grown on shallower soils, did not. Quality in 2025 is real but uneven. The vintage rewards the reader who pays attention to the parcel and the picking date, not the label alone.
The Bordeaux 2025 Campaign That Decides Whether the System Survives
The wines are one story. The campaign that begins releasing them across May and June 2026 is the other, and it is the one that matters more for the way Bordeaux reaches its readers. The 2024 En Primeur saw châteaux cut release prices by an average of 22.5 percent, and even at those reductions, sales fell roughly 60 percent against 2023. Several UK merchants publicly declined selected allocations. Edouard Moueix, of the Libourne négociant house Jean-Pierre Moueix, said before this year’s tastings began that if the 2025 campaign fails, En Primeur is dead.
Liv-ex has framed the same point in commercial language. A recent commentary from the secondary market exchange asked simply that buying en primeur “become a pleasure again.” The system was built on the premise that buyers accepted the early-release discount in exchange for tying up capital for two years. When the discount narrows, or when post-release pricing falls below the EP price, the premise breaks. It has been breaking since 2022.
The value reference point sits in the resale market. As of spring 2026, the Liv-ex 2010 Bordeaux index trades at roughly £6,100 a case-equivalent, about 21 percent below where it sat at release. The broader 2010 average has fallen further. If the 2025s open at or below 2024 levels, the math for the patient buyer is straightforward: pay for the vintage at the level the trade thinks it will hold, not at the level the producer believes it deserves. Whether the châteaux read the room remains the open question of May.
Where to Look on the Right Bank
For readers who track En Primeur for the discoveries rather than the trophies, the limestone Right Bank is where the value sits this year. Château La Gaffelière and Beau-Séjour Bécot in Saint-Émilion drew the cleanest praise from the iDealwine tastings; both estates own the soils that buffered the drought. In Pomerol, where the report cards were more cautious, Château Nénin and Château Rouget held their texture without the heaviness that afflicted lesser sites. Château Taillefer, lower in the Pomerol hierarchy, typically lands in a sub-€40 in-bond bracket on release. None of these are speculative; all of them are wines that an attentive cellar should already know.
The Médoc, for those buying cabernet, will reward the same patience. Pontet-Canet and Beychevelle have historically been among the earliest Médoc releasers, with value-tier names like Lafon-Rochet often following; the speed and confidence of those opening tranches will signal how the rest of the campaign moves. Watch the discount to 2024, not the discount to back vintages.
The Verdict That Arrives in Two Parts
The 2025 vintage is two judgments awaiting a single answer. The first is editorial, and it has largely been delivered: at the top of the appellation, this is the best Bordeaux since 2019, and it carries a profile that is chalky, saline, and fresh, and that flatters a generation of readers who have moved on from the high-alcohol Bordeaux of the early 2010s. The second judgment is commercial, and it does not belong to the critics. It belongs to the châteaux who set the opening prices, the merchants who decide whether to take their allocations, and the buyers who decide whether the discount has finally returned. By the end of June, the verdict will be in. For now, the campaign is worth watching the way one watches a long match settle in its final set.
The TERROIR Letter
The story behind every bottle.
One feature. One dispatch. One bottle worth opening. Every Thursday — free.